Athletic All-Americans
2015Thomas Curtin
2011Will Mulherin
2012Will Mulherin
1981Tracy Deely
1981Lori McKee Taylor
1982Steve Hetherington
1987Steve Taylor
1987Tony Williams
1989Brian Walter
2003Marlies Overbeeke
2007Tasmin Fanning
2008Tasmin Fanning

Academic All-Americans
As selected by CoSIDA
2012Francis Dowd 1st
2013Alexander Ziegler 1st
2004Marlies Overbeeke 2nd
2010Matej Muza 2nd
2012Alexander Ziegler 2nd
2010Kelly Phillips 3rd
U - Unanimous Selection
C - Consensus Selection
Y - Academic All-American of the Year