| Year | Name | Team | Selected By | Pos. |
|---|
| 1958 | Carroll Dale | 2nd | AP | E |
| 1959 | Carroll Dale | 1st | FWA, NEA, AP (2nd Team) | E |
| 1963 | Bob Schweickert | 3rd | AP | QB |
| 1964 | Bob Schweickert | 1st | FWA | QB |
| 1966 | George Foussekis | 2nd | AP | DE |
| 1966 | Frank Loria | 1st | AP, FWA, Helms (2nd Team) | S |
| 1967 | Frank Loria C | 1st | AP, UPI, NEA, AFCA, FWA, WC | S |
| 1968 | Mike Widger | 1st | AP, FWA | LB |
| 1972 | Don Strock | 3rd | AP | QB |
| 1981 | Robert Brown | 2nd | NEA | DE |
| 1983 | Bruce Smith | 1st | AFCA, NEA, AP (2nd Team) | DT |
| 1984 | Bruce Smith C | 1st | AP, FWA, AFCA, WC | DT |
| 1986 | Chris Kinzer | 2nd | AP, UPI | PK |
| 1991 | Eugene Chung | 1st | FWA | OT |
| 1993 | Jim Pyne U | 1st | AP, UPI, WC, FWA, AFCA | C |
| 1995 | Cornell Brown C | 1st | AP, UPI, FWA, TSN, FN | DE |
| 1995 | J.C. Price | 3rd | AP | DT |
| 1996 | Cornell Brown | 1st | WC, AP (2nd Team) | DE |
| 1996 | Billy Conaty | 1st | TSN | C |
| 1997 | Pierson Prioleau | 3rd | TSN | ROV |
| 1998 | Corey Moore | 1st | AFCA, AP (2nd Team), TSN (2nd Team), FN (3rd Team) | DE |
| 1998 | Derek Smith | 3rd | FN | OT |
| 1999 | John Engelberger | 2nd | AP | DE |
| 1999 | Anthony Midget | 3rd | TSN | CB |
| 1999 | Corey Moore U | 1st | AP, FWA, AFCA, WC, TSN, FN | DE |
| 1999 | Jamel Smith | 2nd | AP | LB |
| 1999 | Michael Vick | 1st | TSN, AP (2nd Team) | QB |
| 2000 | André Davis | 1st | AFCA | PR |
| 2000 | Matt Lehr | 2nd | WC | OG |
| 2000 | Lee Suggs | 3rd | AP, FN | TB |
| 2000 | Ben Taylor | 3rd | AP | LB |
| 2001 | David Pugh | 3rd | TSN | DT |
| 2001 | Ben Taylor | 2nd | AP, FN, TSN (3rd Team) | LB |
| 2001 | Ronyell Whitaker | 3rd | AP | CB |
| 2002 | Jake Grove | 4th | TSN | C |
| 2002 | Willie Pile | 2nd | TSN | FS |
| 2003 | Jake Grove U | 1st | FWA, AFCA, TSN, WC, AP | C |
| 2003 | DeAngelo Hall | 2nd | TSN | DB |
| 2003 | Kevin Jones C | 1st | TSN, WC, FWA, AFCA, AP (2nd Team) | RB |
| 2005 | Darryl Tapp | 1st | AFCA, AP (2nd Team) | DL |
| 2005 | Jimmy Williams U | 1st | FWA, AFCA, TSN, WC, AP | DB |
| 2006 | Brandon Flowers | 3rd | AP | CB |
| 2007 | Xavier Adibi | 1st | AFCA, AP (3rd Team) | LB |
| 2007 | Brandon Flowers | 1st | AFCA, WC (2nd Team), AP (2nd Team) | DB |
| 2008 | Victor "Macho" Harris | 1st | TSN, AP (2nd Team) | CB |
| AP - Associated Press; FWA - Football Writers Association; NEA - Newspaper Enterprise Association; Helms - Helms Athletic Foundation; UPI - United Press International; AFCA - American Football Coaches Association; WC - Walter Camp; TSN - The Sporting News; FN - Football News |