Athletic All-Americans
2014Devin Carter 141-lb.
2014Joey Dance 125-lbs.
2014Chris Penny 197-lbs.
2015Nick Brascetta 157-lb.
2015Devin Carter 141-lb.
2015Zach Epperly 174-lb.
2015Ty Walz HWT
2016Nick Brascetta 157-lb.
2016Solomon Chishko 141-lb.
2016Zach Epperly 174-lb.
2016Jared Haught 197-lb.
2016David McFadden 165-lb.
2016Ty Walz HWT
2010Chris Diaz 141-lb.
2012Devin Carter 133-lb.
2012Pete Yates 165-lb.
2013Nick Brascetta 149-lb.
2013Jarrod Garnett 125-lb.
2013Zach Neibert 141-lb.
2013Pete Yates 165-lb.
1959Brandon Glover 130-lb.
1994Josh Feldman HWT
2000Sean Gray 141-lb.
2000Chris Martin 165-lb.
2001Sean Gray 141-lb.
2006Mike Faust HWT
2006David Hoffman 141-lb.

Swimming & Diving and Wrestling: The top eight places in each event at the NCAA Championship are awarded All-American.

Academic All-Americans
As selected by CoSIDA
2015Devin Carter 1stMen's At-Large
2014Devin Carter 2ndMen's At-Large
2006Mike Faust 3rdMen's At-Large
U - Unanimous Selection
C - Consensus Selection
Y - Academic All-American of the Year